Finn Balor's selfie with his cat, Bowie, has caught the attention of a former Judgment Day member and WWE Superstar. Balor has been a part of the faction since 2022, when he replaced Edge.After joining the heel faction, Balor became stablemates with Rhea Ripley, Dominik Mysterio, and Damian Priest. At SummerSlam 2024, Balor betrayed Priest, and Mysterio turned his back on Ripley, marking both of their exits from the group.Another superstar who left The Judgment Day is Carlito. He departed the company in June 2025 after his contract had expired. The 46-year-old superstar reacted to Balor sharing a selfie with his cat and admitted that he also wants a cat for himself."I want to get a cat so bad, mate!" wrote Carlito.Check out a screengrab of Carlito's comment on Balor's post:Carlito spoke about his role in The Judgment DayCarlito opened up about his time with The Judgment Day, stating that he wanted to add a comedic touch to the faction. The former WWE star said that he ran with the idea of WWE creative not having anything for him and turned it into something.Speaking on the Busted Open Radio, he said:"Those were all my ideas. I took, literally, 'creative has nothing for you,' and I made something of it. I went in there and I said, 'I'm not going to complain.' I'm one of the older guys, I'm not going to get prioritized and I'm not gonna get pushed and [Triple H] is not a fan of Carlito." [H/T: The Takedown On SI]Carlito returned to WWE at the 2021 Royal Rumble Match as a babyface. Fast forward to 2023, he returned to a monster pop at the Backlash premium Live Event, working alongside the Latino World Order. He then began a feud with Santos Escobar before turning heel post-WrestleMania XL. Post-SummerSlam 2024, he was revealed as an official member of the newer version of The Judgment Day, which also included Liv Morgan.