The true story behind the Michael Schallert and Afton Ferris case on Snapped: Behind Bars season 3

Snapped: Behind Bars season 3 opens with the case of a double homicide committed by Michael Schallert and Afton Ferris that shook West Frankfort, Illinois. The former couple, both serving life sentences, now speak from prison and present clashing accounts of what happened the night two women were killed.

The episode revisits the October 2009 murders of Kandis Majors, 28, and Terri Seibeck, 32. The women, who had let Ferris and Schallert stay in their home, were found shot multiple times after failing to show up for work. Investigators quickly focused on the pair, who were later arrested in Colorado. Police recovered the victims’ car, credit cards, and a small-caliber handgun.

KFVS reported that both suspects confessed soon after their capture and that a handwritten poem titled “Bullets and Weed” was recovered as evidence. According to Oxygen.com, Schallert later pleaded guilty to two counts of murder, while Ferris was convicted of first-degree murder, and both received life without parole.

---

What happened in the case on Snapped: Behind Bars season 3

Police tape outside a home after two roommates were found shot (Image via Pexels)

Majors and Seibeck had taken in Ferris and Schallert as roommates. The arrangement broke down amid a dispute over missing items, and the couple was told to leave. Less than a day later, the victims were found dead inside the home, with no clear signs of forced entry. Investigators tracked purchases on a victim’s card and located the suspects in Fort Collins, Colorado.

KFVS reported that officers found blood-stained clothing, stolen identification, and the handgun linked to the shootings. The poem, reportedly signed by Ferris, described running with a “handful of bullets,” a detail later discussed on Oxygen’s programming.

These steps, combined with statements to police, formed the backbone of the prosecution. KFVS reported these details in contemporaneous coverage.

---

What the prison interviews add in Snapped: Behind Bars season 3

The new season features separate interviews taped in March 2025. Each inmate adds fresh claims and points the finger at the other. Schallert alleges Ferris pushed a plan to split the blame. Ferris claims she was manipulated and under his influence.

Their stories diverge on planning, motive, and who fired which shots. The show presents those allegations with context from the case file and prior recordings. According to Oxygen.com, both maintain positions that challenge earlier statements, which raises new questions for viewers while the convictions stand.

---

Where to stream and watch Snapped: Behind Bars season 3

New episodes air on Oxygen at 6/5c. Past episodes and extras are available on the Oxygen app and site. Oxygen.com lists season information, episode guides, and previews for the premiere.

---

What Snapped: Behind Bars season 3 covers

The series returns to cases first told on Snapped, then goes inside prisons for new interviews. Inmates recount their choices, investigators outline the timeline, and families describe the aftermath.

Snapped: Behind Bars (Image via Oxygen)

The format relies on case files, archival materials, and sit-downs with those involved. For this premiere, the focus stays on West Frankfort, the arrests in Colorado, the reported confessions, and the claims each inmate now makes about the other. Oxygen provides the show description and the interview context used in the episode.

---

Catch Snapped: Behind Bars season 3 episode 1 on Oxygen.