Samantha Dean case on Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4 - A complete timeline of events

Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4 opens with a harrowing story from Central Texas. The season premiere, The Ultimate Betrayal, revisits the 2015 murder of Samantha Dean, a victims' services counselor who was seven months pregnant. The episode, which aired on November 9, 2025, presents the case in a clear timeline, from initial discovery to courtroom outcomes.

Dean was found in Bastrop, Texas beside her black Dodge Charger at about 2:09 am on February 4, 2015. Investigators soon learned that she was expecting a daughter whom she planned to name Madeline. The case drew wide attention inside law enforcement circles, since Dean worked closely with police agencies and victim families.

According to Oxygen, the scene appeared staged to look like a drug deal, with marijuana placed over blood inside the car. The autopsy showed three gunshot wounds.

---

Background in Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4

Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4 (Image via Oxygen)

Born with a goal of serving the public, Dean had long wanted a police career. Health setbacks changed that path, so she chose victim advocacy instead. Colleagues in Austin and Kyle described her as steady under pressure and gifted at calming families in crisis.

According to KVUE, her parents later shared that Dean had survived cancer years earlier and felt grateful for the pregnancy, which doctors once thought might be unlikely.

Her personal life included an on-and-off relationship with Austin police officer Vontrey Clark. Friends told investigators he was the baby’s father. Early on, that detail stayed private, reportedly because Clark was in another relationship.

---

Murder in Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4

On the night of February 3, Dean withdrew cash at 9:36 pm, then drove toward Bastrop. Phone activity pointed to a meeting that night. She was likely shot shortly after 10:00 pm, then moved inside the car. There were no shell casings and no immediate suspects. As Oxygen reported, detectives believed the crime scene had been altered to mislead them.

Leads grew after threatening texts were sent to a fellow counselor from a burner phone. Purchases traced those phones to Clark’s longtime acquaintance Kevin Watson. Cell data later placed multiple devices tied to Clark, Watson, and Freddie Smith near the scene. At this stage, investigators described the men as persons of interest, and actions were allegedly coordinated with prepaid phones.

---

Investigation in Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4

A fourth man, Aaron Williams, told authorities that Smith admitted being with Clark and Watson the night of the killing, reportedly saying, “they killed that girl.” According to Oxygen, geolocation records showed a convoy to the parking lot. Prosecutors said Clark lured Dean under false pretenses and used her phone to make it look like a drug meet.

Clark soon fled to Indonesia and was later returned to Texas after an international search. The Austin American-Statesman reported that cell forensics, burner phone histories, and travel records tied the group to a murder-for-hire plot, with payments promised to Watson and Smith.

---

Trial and verdict in Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4

Court outcomes arrived over several years. Clark pleaded guilty to capital murder in 2019 and received life without parole, per the Austin American-Statesman. Watson took a plea deal and received 35 years, as Oxygen noted. Smith went to trial in 2022, was found guilty of capital murder, and was sentenced to life in prison.

Killer Relationship With Faith Jenkins season 4 (Image via Oxygen)

In 2025, Kyle Police dedicated victim interview rooms in honor of Samantha and her unborn daughter, Madeline, according to KVUE. The episode closes the loop by laying out each step in order, from the first 2:09 am discovery to the final sentences, so viewers can follow the full arc without guesswork.

---